In many ways it was more comfortable to be a large fish in a small East Rand Soccer pond, rather than a small fish in a very big South African rugby pond! But as enrolment at St Benedict’s grew, it became increasingly clear that to maintain proper sporting relationships with comparable Boys’ High and Catholic Schools (all of whom played rugby rather than soccer!) Bennies needed to switch to Rugby. The matter had been discussed and debated for a number of years. Finally in 1997 it was decided that the College would change to Rugby from 1998.

The decision was welcomed by the boys and the introduction of Rugby at the College in 1998 was painless and brought about an instantaneous transformation within the school. The season was a true eye opener for all concerned as the open side played 8 games, won 1 against St John’s 3rd side and only managed to score 3 points the whole season with 350 points scored against them.

Success came rapidly! By the year 2000, Bennies were regularly beating some of the more experienced rugby schools. In 2002, Mr Cheese Van Tonder (Junior Bok, SAXV, SA Varsity, SA Barbarians, SA Colleges, SA Defense Force, Free State & Transvaal player) took over as the Director of Rugby. Our rugby took huge strides forward because of the expert training and guidance the boys received. By 2005, St Benedict’s were playing against some of the top schools in the country, and beating the likes of Helpmekaar, Parktown Boys’ Potch Boys’ , St Albans, St David's, Jeppe, St John’s and King Edward.

Bennies have now become a regular feature at the Easter Invitational festivals, and will this year be in action at the KES Fest due to our strong performance of 2009 in which we were undefeated at the prestigious festival. Currently St Benedict’s has 18 rugby teams, a far cry from the 5 of 1998.

St Benedict’s have produced 2 Craven week players, Jarrod Taylor in 2003 and Srdjan Dabovic in 2008. St Benedict’s have also produced numerous provincial players in the younger age groups. In 2008 we also had 2 boys representing the school in the Lions Academy sides.

Spectators watching St Benedict’s Preparatory School are treated to exciting "running rugby". We encourage team spirit, fitness and above all commitment. St Benedict’s Rugby has come a long way in the 10 years since its inception. The challenge to become the best may not be easy, but it is possible!